If you’re not a communist…

There’s an old saying:

If you’re not a communist at the age of 20, you haven’t got a heart.
If you’re still a communist at the age of 30, you haven’t got a brain.

I’ve always liked this quote, and have wondered about its origin since I first heard it. Now, thanks to the web — invented when I was about 25 — I can find out. It turns out to pre-date communism by some time, at least as a rhetorical device.

It was said about republicanism by François Guizot, the French Prime Minister in the mid 19th century, whose childhood had been during the Reign of Terror.

Not to be a republican at 20 is proof of want of heart; to be one at 30 is proof of want of head.

It was later adopted by Georges Clemenceau, who substituted socialiste for republicain.

But, Fred Shapiro points out, one could argue that even Guizot was pipped to the post by John Adams, who said something similar, though not as elegantly, in 1799:

A boy of 15 who is not a democrat is good for nothing, and he is no better who is a democrat at 20.

Adams missed the heart and head distinction, though, which I think is important: it captures the sometimes misguided fervour of youth and the wisdom that comes from experience (or, others might say, the conservatism that comes from age).

Of course, I still prefer the ‘communist’ version, but that’s because of when I grew up. I wonder what variations will be popular in 50 or 100 years’ time?

Enjoyed this post? Why not sign up to receive Status-Q in your inbox?


Nice history. Disraeli, one of my favourite politicians, from nineteenth century, also has a very similar quote ascribed to him. As a device, it is always used to dismiss the hot ideologies of youth. But pause a moment: how often do we use intellect to defend the indefensible, by pretending the emotional side should/can be downplayed?

Heh, I first heard this in an interview with Steve Jobs during his NeXT days. His version was along the lines of: If you’re don’t vote democrat when you’re young, you have no heard; if you don’t vote republican when you’re older, you heave no brains.

At the time I assumed it was his phrase, but glad to see he was just doing what great artists do 🙂

I would more than love to be a communist as long as I don’t have to live in a communist country and be a practicing one

Very interesting. The intention of the phrase itself I have always taken umbrage with, it simplifies all political dialogue into the sweet but naive left and the stoically practical and inevitable right, and it makes assumptions about both. Basically saying that it is a youthful conceit to try and make the world better, but when you are in a position to actually do something about it you should forget a better world and just try to get by under the current rules. The funny thing about it is, of course, that studies show that in general if not always in specific cases, the right wing are less intelligent than the left. While there are loons and kooks on both sides, moderate left wing governments outperform moderate right wing governments in the economic field, and such things as climate denial and mythology based politics is more common on the right.

A communist is somebody who has nothing and wants to share it with everybody else

I feel that communism is necessary for ensuring an egalitarian society. However, unfortunately, the way communism was implemented in USSR and certain East European nations had given bad name to communist ideology. We should study the principles of communism properly and evolve methods and procedures to implement them in an acceptable way. Violence and forcible deprivation have to be shunned at any cost.

There was a time when I felt, there’s no option for the world but to be communist. Implementation has been wrong.

Got Something To Say:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To create code blocks or other preformatted text, indent by four spaces:

    This will be displayed in a monospaced font. The first four 
    spaces will be stripped off, but all other whitespace
    will be preserved.
    Markdown is turned off in code blocks:
     [This is not a link](http://example.com)

To create not a block, but an inline code span, use backticks:

Here is some inline `code`.

For more help see http://daringfireball.net/projects/markdown/syntax


© Copyright Quentin Stafford-Fraser